Showing posts with label Yankees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yankees. Show all posts

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Don't call it a comeback!

On second thought, yeah, let's call it a comeback.

I understand the hatred of Carl Pavano. Anyone who had been paying attention knew it was a dumb signing -- Pavano had one good year amid lots of injuries. But, four years and $39.95 million later, now the Yankees know it too.

But I don't get the "Pavano sucks" attitude I've been hearing on sports talk radio the last couple days. Pavano hasn't sucked. He hasn't been good, he hasn't earned his $39.95 million, he hasn't been what the Yankees apparently thought they were getting when they stupidly signed him in 2005, but he hasn't sucked. He's been either mediocre or absent.

2005: 4-6, 18 BB, 56 K, 4.77 ERA, 1.47 WHIP
2006: DNP
2007: 1-0, 2 BB, 4 K, 4.76 ERA, 1.24 WHIP
2008: ?
TOTAL: 5-6, 20 BB, 60 K, 4.77 ERA, 1.45 WHIP


Remember Ed Whitson and Steve Trout? Those guys sucked. They get an F. Pavano gets an incomplete. He just hasn't been here. I'm not sure which one is worse, the guy who shows up but can't get it done, or the guy who is borderline competent on the rare occasion he feels like playing.

Well, apparently he feels like playing now. We need a starter, so it's Pavano or Phil Hughes, who has been having a tough time in Triple-A (8.47 ERA, 1.65 WHIP). And personally, if you're going to rush a guy back, I'd rather it be Pavano. Or maybe you'd rather see Kei Igawa?

Insert 'I'd like to show her who's the Boss' joke here(Heck, if he was still with Alyssa Milano, I'd actually be looking forward to today's start. He also was dumped by Gia Allemand after he cheated on her. Apparently this wasn't good enough for Carl. He may have problems using his arm, but apparently not his penis.)

The knock on Glass Carl was that he pitched terribly -- or not at all -- until his contract year in '04, and suddenly he was good (18-8, 3.00 ERA, 1.17 WHIP). That's not exactly fair as he wasn't terrible in '03 (12-13, 4.30 ERA, 1.26 WHIP), but Pavano hasn't done anything in his Yankee career to convince us that he is willing to play through even the slightest discomfort. (Stiff neck, tight back... Bruised buttocks, anyone?)

Now at the end of this season his contract is up. The conspiracy theorists should be expecting a good September, right? Suddenly he feels good enough to pitch again. If Carl wants another contract this off-season, he should be in line for five or six quality starts.

I'll take it.

Oh, and as I pointed out to D. Isaac yesterday -- of the five catchers Pavano has thrown to most often in his career, who has the lowest OPS allowed?

Ivan RodriguezOf course -- Ivan Rodriguez. When pitching to Pudge, Pavano has allowed a .257/.307/.408 (.715 OPS) line, compared to .276/.330/.427 (.757) overall. Yes, Rodriguez caught him during his only good run ('03-'04), and yes, that was in the N.L. Still, it's something to keep in mind.

I'm not busting out the Carl Pavano jersey for today's start. I'm just saying let's wring whatever we can get out of this waste of a contract and move on.

Monday, May 19, 2008

Same as it ever was...

Well, Yankee fans, here we are again, 20-24, 6 games out. But hey, look at the bright side - last year we had the very same record but were 10-1/2 games out.

And last year things got worse -- we'd finish the month 22-29 -- before they got better. But we went 72-39 the rest of the way.

So yeah, it's possible we'll do that again and win the wild card, maybe even the division. But wouldn't it be nice if this team could play all six months of the season, instead of only the last four?

It's just not easy to beat a guy like Oliver Perez with five lefties in the lineup (and when one of the righties is Alberto Gonzalez).


Perez vs RHB: .285 BA, .390 OBP, .398 SLG
Perez vs LHB: .094 BA, .269 OBP, .208 SLG


I don't know why Girardi left Morgan Ensberg and Shelley Duncan on the bench; you would think their only purpose in life is to mash guys like Ollie. If you aren't going to use them last night, why have them on the team? I do realize that Ensberg is hitting .214 (.179 vs LHP) and Duncan is hitting .194 (.240 vs LHP), but it's not like Giambi and Cano are hitting either. If they put Gonzalez at second, Ensberg at third and Duncan at first, do they win the game? Who knows. Maybe Duncan doesn't waste an out in the 4th inning the way Giambi did (trying to force Carlos Beltran instead of getting the easier out at first), and the Mets don't score 4 runs that inning. Maybe the offense produces more than 2 runs. Or maybe they get shut out, who knows.

All I know is this is a very frustrating team to watch right now, and when things were bleak last year, it was guys like Duncan who fired up the team and finally got them playing with some heart again.

Get them in the game, Joe. At this point, what do we have to lose?

Sunday, April 27, 2008

That hurts!

The Yankees have suddenly been hit with a couple big injuries.

Jorge Posada has a "tear in his subscapularis muscle"... that doesn't sound good. What sounds even worse is he's going to go visit with Dr. James Andrews. Andrews had earlier said he didn't think Posada would need surgery, but the shoulder hasn't gotten any better. At this point all we know is he is probably going on the D.L. for the first time in his 13-year career.

Adding to the frustration, the Yankees just designated Chad Moeller for assignment, so now it's just Jose Molina and presumably Chris Stewart from Scranton (.270 BA, .737 OPS). Stewart is an intriguing fellow as he has a .386 OBP... in 37 ABs, he has 7 walks and 0 strikeouts. But don't get too excited -- he has a career .313 OBP (.252 BA, .361 SLG) in seven minor league seasons. If Moeller clears waivers maybe they'll bring him back, or troll the free agent catcher market and see who needs a job. Does anyone have Mike Lieberthal's phone number? I guess if all else fails we can always suit up Girardi for old times' sake.

Then there's Brian Bruney, who suffered the dreaded Lisfranc injury and might be gone for the rest of the season. I know Bruney wasn't high on anyone's pre-season "Yankees I hope don't get Lisfranc'd" list, but he was one of our best non-Joba middle relief options this year (11.1 IP, 7 H, 2 ER, 6 BB, 12 K).

Luckily we have a lot of depth at Triple-A when it comes to bullpen help. Edwar Ramirez has been just filthy in Scranton (9.0 IP, 2 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 13 K). Jose Veras (11.0 IP, 7 H, 2 ER, 4 BB, 18 K), Heath Phillips (12.2 IP, 3 H, 3 ER, 4 BB, 11 K) and Sean Henn (6.2 IP, 5 H, 1 ER, 1 BB, 7 K) have pitched well also. I think you call up Edwar and hope Ross Ohlendorff gets straightened out.

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Your number is up...

So, LaTroy Hawkins has given up No. 21...

I have mixed feelings about this whole situation.

First, I don't really like Hawkins. The Yankees desperately needed middle relief help, but Hawkins? The guy with a career 4.70 ERA, 1.47 WHIP? Check his career numbers against Boston (5.23 ERA, 1.39 WHIP), Cleveland (5.27, 1.78) and Anaheim/Los Angeles (5.85, 1.73), the A.L.'s three post-season teams last year.

Most alarming of all, the Yankees have hit Hawkins to the tune of a 6.44 ERA, 1.61 WHIP and .327 BAA. Wouldn't it have made more sense for us to pay another team to take him? He helps us more when he's pitching for an opponent!

We've been collecting guys like this since the end of the great Ramiro Mendoza/Mike Stanton/Jeff Nelson triumverate. He's a proud successor to the heritage of Luis Vizcaino, Felix Rodriguez, Felix Heredia, Paul Quantrill and Antonio Osuna.

But there weren't a lot of great middle relievers available this off-season, and we needed somebody who could throw strikes. (For all his faults, he doesn't give up a lot of walks... just hits.) Frankly, Hawkins isn't a problem if he's a mop-up guy, and hopefully that's what he'll be as I'm assuming Joe Girardi knows that Brian Bruney and Ross Ohlendorf are both better options to bridge the gap to Joba and Mo.

But I think it was stupid to boo a guy for his number. If the Yankees wanted to retire No. 21, they didn't need LaTroy's permission to do it. And the bottom line is? I don't think the number should be retired.

Paul O'Neill was a very good player who I will always remember, but retired numbers should be for the true Yankee greats, and he wasn't. He's like Hank Bauer, Roy White, Tommy Tresh. Guys who are beloved by the fans of that generation, but an immortal? I'm sorry, but when you make your list of all-time Yankee outfielders, where do you put the Warrior? In terms of runs created as a Yankee, he ranks eighth (858), between Bob Meusel (876) and Tommy Henrich (856). Don't like runs created? OK, in career OPS, he's 9th (.869) among Yankee OFs, behind the likes of Charlie Keller (.928), George Selkirk (.883), and, again, Henrich (.873). If you want to use Adjusted OPS to take into account his era, it doesn't help your case: He's now tied for 13th at 125 with Hideki Matsui, Bernie Williams and Birdie Cree. (Henrich is 9th.)

I don't point this out to denigrate O'Neill, who, as I said, was a very good player and by all accounts a very nice, very funny guy. In 40 years, I will tell my grandchildren stories about O'Neill's legendary tantrums and the crowd chanting his name in 2001. It doesn't matter if there's a No. 21 plaque on the wall or not. And they'll think of O'Neill the way I think of Henrich, a very good player who belongs to my grandfather's generation.

I like what the Yankees had done with O'Neill's number, leave it out of circulation for a little while, then quietly bring it back. (Honestly, if it were up to me, I'd make Numbers 1 and 9 available again too, but that ain't gonna happen.) I don't remember any outrage when Morgan Ensberg wore 21 in spring training. I wonder what would've happened if he had just kept it? Could it be that No. 21 just looks better on a white guy?

All that said... Hawkins had a 9.00 ERA and 1.86 WHIP as No. 21; last night, as No. 22, he pitched two scoreless innings, giving up just one hit and striking out 2, and earned his first Yankee win. So maybe the fans were right after all.

Saturday, February 9, 2008

Schilling's shoulder

I guess whatever miraculous healing power Curt Schilling used on his ankle doesn't work for shoulders.

Or maybe they test for it now.

Either way, it looks like Schilling is out until at least the All-Star Break, if not the year. Or his career could be over.

I have two reasons to hate Schilling - 2001 World Series, 2004 ALCS. But I also have two reasons not to hate him - I like that he has a game design company (yes, I'm a geek), and I like that he has done so much to fight ALS, even naming his son Gehrig.

So on balance those cancel out.

No, not really. Fuck him and his ketchup-leaking ankle. Why couldn't anyone try to drop a bunt on that pudgy gimp? Ridiculous. But at least I'll be able to hate him a lot less if his career is over.

What I'm really wondering today is how Red Sox fans feel about him right now. They all loved him and his bloody sock. They loved his trash-talking on his blog and Sons of Sam Horn. But you have to wonder how they would have gone about their business this off-season if they'd known they might be without Schilling this year.

The Red Sox certainly wouldn't have signed Schilling to that $8 million one-year contract if they knew his shoulder tendon looked like "three strands of spaghetti." (What's it supposed to look like, rigatoni?) And even if they had signed him to a bargain-basement contract, they could have insisted on surgery back in November.

But would they have been more aggressive in going after Johan Santana, Erik Bedard or Dan Haren?

Red Sox fans are saying the loss of Schilling is no big deal, they only gave him 150 innings and 9 wins last year. But there's a big difference between having a starting rotation of four veterans and one rookie, and three veterans and two rookies - especially when one of those veterans is Tim Wakefield, who also battled shoulder problems last year. Josh Beckett is unquestionably an ace, and Daisuke Matsuzaka should be better after adjusting to the league last year. But after that? They can turn within and try Jon Lester, Clay Buchholz, Devern Hansack and/or Kyle Snyder. The Yankees tried the rookie-of-the-month rotation the first half of last year and it didn't work so well, so good luck with that.

More likely they'll trade for a veteran - maybe Joe Blanton, but you know Billy Beane isn't going to just give him away - or sign whoever is still out there. Bartolo Colon, Kris Benson, Steve Trachsel, Shawn Chacon... Yeah, it's ugly.

I don't want to oversell the loss of Schilling - no one is suggesting you can now write the Red Sox off. But it certainly changes the dynamic heading into 2008. And if I was a Red Sox fan, I'd rather have known about Schilling in November, instead of a week before pitchers and catchers report.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Deal or no deal?

Let's say you run the Yankees and I run the Red Sox, and in the interest of putting aside our long-standing rivalry, we should make a fair trade that will make everybody happy.

How about you trade me 21-year-old right-hander Phil Hughes for 24-year-old left-hander Jon Lester.

Hughes, in 13 MLB starts, has a 4.46 ERA and a 1.28 WHIP, with 29 BB and 58 K in 72.2 IP; in the minors, a 2.09 ERA and a 0.86 WHIP with 66 BB and 311 Ks in 275 IP.

Lester, in 26 MLB starts, has a 4.68 ERA, 1.46 WHIP, 74 BB and 110 K in 144.1 IP; in the minors, a 3.33 ERA, 1.31 WHIP, 203 BB and 446 K in 484 IP.

What? No deal?

OK. How about if Lester came with Coco Crisp, a 28-year-old center fielder who hit .268 with a .712 OPS last year (career .280, .738) and will make $4.75 million next year. Would that convince you to make the deal?

Oh wait - but you have to throw in 22-year-old Melky Cabrera, who hit .273 with a .718 OPS last year (career .280, .728) and makes $432,400. Does that make the deal better?

No? Sheesh. OK, how about if I also give you 22-year-old right-hander Justin Masterson (4.34 ERA, 1.16 WHIP, 18 BB, 59 K in Double-A). But you have to also include 22-year-old right-hander Jeff Marquez (3.65 ERA, 1.35 WHIP, 44 BB, 94 K in Double-A).

Still won't pull the trigger? Fine. I'll throw in 23-year-old middle infielder Jed Lowrie (.300, .862 OPS in Triple-A).

What is wrong with you?

Alright, stop whining. Let's try a different deal. How about you give me Hughes, Cabrera and Marquez, and instead of Lester and Crisp, I'll give you Lowrie, Masterson and... (drumroll)... Jacoby Ellsbury! The 23-year-old center fielder hit .353/.394/.509 in 116 major league at-bats last year, and .314/.390/.426 over a three-year minor league career. No question he's a good young hitter... a good enough hitter to get me Hughes, wouldn't you say?

No?... you are impossible to deal with!

If the Twins don't think Hughes and Cabrera is enough for Johan Santana, that's fine. But how anyone can think that Lester/Crisp or just Ellsbury is a better offer just boggles my mind.

Baseball America graded out four offers for Santana and say either of the Red Sox offers is better than the Yankee offer. (The Mets offer comes out last, if only because all the players involved are so young that they're all gambles.) Obviously I know far less about baseball than the people at Baseball America. But on what planet is Hughes not worth more than Ellsbury or Lester+Crisp?

Are Masterson and Lowrie so much more valuable than Cabrera and Marquez that it makes up for the difference with Hughes?

Young pithers are a fragile commodity, I get that. The long list of superstars-to-be who never made it is long and sad. I'm sure you can find guys with minor league numbers as good or better than Hughes who never made it. But you can make that same argument about Lester or Masterson or any other young pitcher.

And I'm not trying to sell Cabrera as being on Ellsbury's level. (But surely he's worth more than Crisp!) But if you had Hughes, would you really trade him for Ellsbury straight up?

I'm not buying any of this. I think the Twins want Hughes, but they're also trying to get Ian Kennedy or somebody else out of the Yankees, and the Yankees are sticking to their initial offer. So what do you do if you're the Twins? Of course, you run to the Red Sox and Mets, say their offers are better, and hope the Yankees bite and put more on the table.

But Baseball America would trade Hughes and Melky for Lester and Crisp?

Really?

Sunday, November 25, 2007

Will the status quo be good enough?

The Yankees are putting the band back together.



I was hoping for two out of the big three - Alex Rodriguez, Mariano Rivera and Jorge Posada - and they got all three. And Andy Pettitte is still flirting with retirement, but he might be back, too. For all the talk after the Cleveland series about the end of the dynasty (which has been pronounced "ended" every year since 2001), the 2008 Yankees may be the same team as the 2007 Yankees.

Guys like Steve Phillips like to say that's not good enough. The Yankees can't be as good as they were last year -- they have to be better. Because, after all, they didn't win the World Series last year, so they have to try to be better, right? (Yes, these are the same guys who say every year that the Yankees are stupid for thinking they can win the World Series every year.)

But which 2007 Yankees will these 2008 Yankees be? The first half of 2007, when their Opening Day starter was Carl Pavano, and when the rest of the rotation was whoever could make the next train from Scranton?

Apparently Phillips thinks the Yankees will tie the Major League record they set last year by using 10 different starters (six of them rookies) in their first 30 games.

Let's remember: At the end of May, 22-29. At the end of September, 94-68. That's 72-39 -- a .649 winning percentage. Over a full season, that's 105 wins.

The same team, but with a better manager, a full year of Joba and Hughes, and a reasonable, non-record setting number of injuries? I'll take the status quo.

All I ask is a decent lefty in the 'pen... and better bug spray.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Posada's Pay-Day

You'd be smiling too, if you just got a $13.1 million a year contract.

Yes, following the 2010 season, this may look like a lousy deal. But I think the Yankees did what they had to do to re-sign Jorge Posada, closing what would have been a far bigger hole than the one at third base.

It's true that we won't be able to find a third baseman with 54 home runs, 156 runs batted in and a 1.067 OPS -- or even one with 35 HRs, 139 RBIs and a .915 OPS, what Alex Rodriguez did in his "off year" of 2006. But the drop-off from A-Rod to whoever plays third for the Yankees, even if it's a worst-case-scenario platoon of Wilson Betemit and Aaron Bleeping Boone, won't be as ugly as the drop from Posada to Jason LaRue or Damian Miller or Yorvit Torrealba. Now that Posada's off the market, the best option available is arguably Paul Lo Duca, who hit .272 but with a ridiculously empty .689 OPS, or maybe Michael Barrett, who hit .244 with a .653, but is a guy a smart organization would target with a one-year make-good contract. After that it's all guys who should be back-ups.

Posada isn't a great defensive catcher. Over the years, he's improved when it comes to throwing out baserunners -- from awful to below average -- and for a lot of people, that's the only factor they consider when it comes to evaluating a catcher's defense. But Jorge allows a lot of passed balls -- 13 in 1111.3 innings last year. On the ESPN leader board, that's the fourth-most in the majors. That doesn't count all the wild pitches that are charged to the pitcher but that an average catcher probably could have blocked. And when you watch a Yankee game, what's even more frustrating are the pitches that simply pop out of his glove. The ball doesn't get far enough away for the runner to advance, or there's no one on base anyway, so it doesn't go down as a passed ball. But how often is an umpire going to give you a strike if the catcher drops the ball?

All that said, here's a catcher coming off a career year -- .338 BA, .426 OBP, .543 SLG -- in a very weak market for free agent catchers. To quote Teddy KGB, "Pay that man his money."



Jorge isn't likely to put up those numbers again, so what's a reasonable projection for next year? How about he hits .262 with a .782 OPS, which is what he did in 2005 -- his worst numbers since '99, when he was still sharing the job with his new manager. That seems like a reasonable expectation for a minimum level of production for the next two or three years.

That's 100 more points in OPS than you'll get from any other catcher on the market. And 100 points in OPS makes up for a lot of passed balls.

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Donnie Baseball or Joltin' Joe Girardi-O?

The New York Daily News and Sports Illustrated's Jon Heyman reported today that Joe Girardi will be the next Yankee manager.

I don't buy it.

I think it will be Don Mattingly. And more than that, I think it should be Mattingly. Or at least, shouldn't be Girardi.

The Daily News had this lovely little chart today with the pros and cons for each managerial candidate -- Girardi, Mattingly and Tony Pena, who, let's face it, was there just to fulfill the MLB requirement that you speak to a minority. (After Pena interviewed, the headline on the back of the New York Post should have been: "The Token Has Spoken.")

Anyway, so here's this chart that was in the Daily News today:



I don't think you can disagree with the idea that, when it comes to the '08 Yankees, the most important category out of those four is "handling of pitching staff." Phil Hughes, Joba Chamberlain and Ian Kennedy are three terrific young arms, and Chien-Ming Wang has to get straightened out. After 12 years of watching Torre falling asleep in the dugout, "Game strategy/decision-making" is obviously not a priority with this team. I don't think either "Communication with players" or "Relationship with front office" will be a problem with either guy.

So, if I was advising the Yankees, my priority would be getting a guy who knows how to handle a pitching staff. And, according to the Daily News article, that's one of Brian Cashman's top priorities, too. Good, so we're all on the same page.

But why does Girardi get four checkmarks for handling the pitching staff? "Because he used to be a catcher, and catchers know how to handle pitchers." Really? Joe Torre used to be a catcher, how were his pitcher handling skills?

I have three reasons why Girardi shouldn't get any positive marks for handling the pitching staff: Josh Johnson, Anibal Sanchez and Dontrelle Willis.

Johnson was probably the reason Girardi got fired. Girardi brought Johnson back into a game after an 82-minute rain delay and right after that, he hurt his arm. Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria blamed the injury on Johnson pitching after the rain delay. Is he right? Who knows. But if Girardi does the same thing to Joba or Hughes and he gets hurt, will we still be patting him on the back for his great handling of a pitching staff?

And then there's Sanchez. Marlins fans blamed Girardi for Sanchez's injury as well. Sanchez threw 76.1 innings in Single A in 2004, 136 innings between Single A and Double-A in '2005, and then 200 innings between Double-A and the majors in 2006. That includes 114.1 innings in the majors in '06, including six starts in September totaling 43 innings, including two complete games (one of them a no-hitter), and two starts after hurting his hand trying to barehand a comebacker. More evidence of Joe's careful use of young pitching talent?

I really can't fault Girardi for riding Sanchez and Johnson through July and August, as they were realistically in the Wild Card hunt. But by mid-September they were basically out of it.

As for Dontrelle, I don't know what's wrong with this guy. And apparently Girardi doesn't either.


YEAR ERA WHIP K/9 BB/9 K:BB HR/9 IP
2003 3.30 1.28 7.9 3.2 2.4 0.7 160.2
2004 4.02 1.38 6.3 2.8 2.3 0.9 197.0
2005 2.63 1.13 6.5 2.1 3.1 0.4 236.1
2006 3.87 1.42 6.4 3.3 1.9 0.8 223.1
2007 5.17 1.60 6.4 3.8 1.7 1.3 205.1


It doesn't look to me like Girardi, in '06, figured out the key to Dontrelle. Maybe '04 and '06 represent his true ability level and '03 and '05 are the upper limit on his ability. But if Girardi is so good with pitchers, shouldn't he be getting those upper limit results?

Again, where's the evidence Joe has a knack for working with pitchers?

Given his track record, does Girardi really deserve four out of five checks for pitching staff?

And if Girardi isn't good at handling pitchers, what's the point?

Tuesday, October 9, 2007

OK, that didn't work

Four months 'til pitchers and catchers report!

That sucked. Chien-Ming Wang gave up 4 runs on 5 hits and couldn't get an out in the second inning, forcing a switch to Mike Mussina. And while Moose wasn't great (2 ER, 4 H, 4 BB in 4.2 IP, plus he allowed two of Wang's inherited runners to score), he kept the score reasonable. The final score, 6-4, makes it look like it was a nailbiter, but it really wasn't. It was a frustrating, slow, agonizing game. The Yankees had 12 hits, including three home runs and a double, plus 3 walks, but left 10 men on base. Bleh.

Derek Jeter went 2-for-5 with an RBI, but killed us in the bottom of the 6th, grounding into a 4-6-3 double play. The Yankees had runners on the corners and one out; just a fly ball would've made it a three-run game with three innings yet to play. Alex Rodriguez also went 2-for-5 with an RBI (a solo home run in the 7th), but he also came up empty in a big spot, striking out with two on and one out in the bottom of the 1st.

The Yankees teased you a little bit in the bottom of the 9th, as the Indians went to Joe Borowski. After Jeter popped out, Bobby Abreu hit a shot into the upper deck to make it 6-4. "A bloop and a blast" as John Sterling says, incessantly. But no bloops were to be had. A-Rod flew out to right, and then it all came down to Jorge Posada, who in any other year would be every Yankee fan's MVP candidate. Posada drove one down the right field line and Sterling gave us a classic "It is high! It is far! It is... foul!" Then Posada struck out swinging to end it.

Inning over... game over... American League Division Series over... the Indians win, the Indians win.

There's plenty of blame to go around. The list is shorter of guys you can't blame: Robinson Cano (.333, 1.175 OPS), Johnny Damon (.278, .927) and Bobby Abreu (.267, .886), and Andy Pettitte (0 ER, 7 H, 2 BB, 5 K in 6.1 IP), Phil Hughes (1 ER, 3 H, 0 BB, 6 K in 5.2 IP) and Mariano Rivera (0 ER, 2 H, 1 BB, 6 K in 4.2 IP). You can add Moose in there if you want. Joba Chamberlain has ugly numbers (2 ER, 3 H, 3 BB, 4 K in 3.2 IP) but he deserves a pass as all the damage happened in the freakish bug bowl of Game 2 and in his second inning in Game 3, when the game was already won.

So, who's the goat? The two obvious candidates, as always, are A-Rod and Torre.

Blame A-Rod! He didn't come through in the clutch in a couple big spots. But his overall line isn't bad (.267, .820), and considering how much worse some of the other hitters are, it's a real stretch to blame him. Yankee haters always have something to say about Rodriguez -- no matter what he does, they try to talk about him. If he has a horrible night, they kill A-Rod; if he has a great night, they kill Yankee fans for not loving A-Rod enough. But for this particular series anyway, there's just not that much to say. He got some hits, and he made some outs. He's not the story, but some people will try to make him the story anyway.

The rest of the lineup? The Yankees collectively hit .228 and stranded all those runners on base, so let's blame the batters. But which one? Melky Cabrera hit just .188 but he did have the only big hit against Fausto Carmona, and he was great in the field. Matsui had only 2 hits in 11 at-bats, but he also drew 5 walks, so who's going to fault a .438 OBP. Doug Mientkiewicz went 0-for-6 but if you're relying on Minky for offense, you're doomed. Jason Giambi only had 1 hit, but he also had just 4 ABs.

No, if you're going to blame a batter, it's got to be Jeter or Posada. After having great regular seasons, each was really awful in the playoffs. Jeter went 3-for-17 with 3 GIDPs and probably should have been charged with an error in Game 3, but the Yankees won that game anyway. Posada went 2-for-15 and was charged with one passed ball and probably deserved another that went down as a wild pitch to Joba. But you might have a hard time finding a Yankee fan willing to pin anything on either Derek or Georgie, who are not just True Yankees, but were two-thirds of the foundation of the 1996-2001 dynasty.

Blame Torre! Sure, why not? Maybe he could have pulled Wang earlier in Game 1, after the 4th inning, when the Yankees were down 4-3 and had just missed an opportunity to regain the lead (bases loaded, one out, no runs). Maybe he could have delayed Game 2 long enough for the bugs to disperse, or switch to a less tasty reliever. Or I can be a total hypocrite and say he was wrong for starting Wang in Game 4. Hey, I didn't want to bring him back last year so I'm certainly not advocating he be brought back for next year, but in this series, I don't think you can blame Torre.

And how can you fault Torre for how he handled Wang, but not Wang himself? I'm not sure if he's hurt or wore down or if the Indians just had his number, but Wang looked flat-out awful out there. Hell, the Yankee team ERA with Wang was 5.89, without him was 3.48. The Indians team ERA in the series was 3.41. Wang's pre- and post-All-Star break numbers suggest something happened over the second half (3.36 ERA, 1.20 WHIP vs 4.07 ERA, 1.40 WHIP). But again, Wang, as a True Yankee, might not catch a lot of flak. You can try to blame Roger Clemens (3 ER, 4 H, 2 BB, 1 K in 2.1 IP), but the Yankees won that game anyway. Luis Vizcaino blew Game 2, but how do you blame him and not Joba? Ross Ohlendorff coughed up some big runs in Game 1, but again, you can't blame him but not Wang.

The bottom line: Ah, what the fuck. Blame A-Rod and Torre anyway. They won't be here next year.

Monday, October 8, 2007

Well, I think this is good news...

Joe Torre announced after last night's win that today's starter would be Chien-Ming Wang on three days' rest and not Mike Mussina. If we get to a Game 5, Andy Pettitte will be able to pitch on full rest (because of the day off tomorrow).

Torre was criticized last year for not trying this during the Detroit series. In Game 1, Wang was good but not great -- he gave up 3 runs on 8 hits and a walk -- but the Yankees won, 8-4.

Four days later, the Yankees were down 2 games to 1 and at Comerica Park, and there was talk of bringing back Wang on three days' rest. Wang had thrown 93 pitches in 6.2 innings, so it wasn't out of the question that he could come back. Once again, there would be a travel day between Games 4 and 5, so the Game 2 starter -- Mussina, coincidentally -- would be available on the normal four days rest to pitch the final game, if the Yankees got there.

Only Joe knows why, but this was dismissed as a possibility and instead we relied on the trusty arm of Jaret Wright to carry us through Game 4. Nice. Wright was pounded for 4 runs on 5 hits (2 home runs) in just 2.2 innings, and that's all she wrote.

Torre and his defenders (particularly Suzyn Waldman) are big on the "but then who" argument whenever you talk about doing anything unJoe-like. When the Yankees lose a tie game on the road after he trots out Ron Villone to pitch the bottom of the 9th, if you ask Joe, hey, maybe Mariano Rivera could have pitched there, he'll ask: "But then who pitches the bottom of the 10th?" Huh. Well, now that you mention it, yeah, Villone solved that problem for us by blowing the game in the bottom of the 9th.

Of course he can't admit it, but I'm thinking last year Torre was already thinking about the next series, which of course you can never do. He figured, "I can use Wang in Game 4 and Mussina in Game 5, but then who pitches Game 1?" So he figured he'd patch through Game 4 with Wright and Cory Lidle, and that went as well as could be expected.

The difference is, this post-season, Torre is managing with a gun to his head -- literally, if they take my advice -- and that's why he was so quick to pull Roger Clemens, why he burned up Joba Chamberlain for 2 innings, why he used Mariano Rivera with a 4-run lead, why he benched Mussina today for Wang. He's managing like a guy who understands that, in an elimination game, you don't have to worry about tomorrow until you get there. Survive and move on, as they say in the NCAAs.

Despite the fact that Wang got pounded by the Indians in Game 1, I'm confident we'll get a better performance this time. There's that whole "tired is better for sinkerballers" argument, which, who knows if it's true or not. Wang hasn't pitched on three days' rest this year (or last year), so it's hard to reasonably make that argument.

But more importantly, Wang was a lot better at home (10-4, 2.75 ERA, 1.13 WHIP) than on the road (9-3, 4.91, 1.50 WHIP), so I'd rather start him on short rest at Yankee Stadium tonight. And it also works for Game 5 -- Pettitte, somewhat surprisingly for a lefty, is actually slightly worse at Yankee Stadium (8-4, 4.17, 1.44) than on the road (7-5, 3.95, 1.41).

This makes sense all around. So much so, that I'm surprised Joe thought of it. The barrel of a .45 pressed firmly against his temple may have had something to do with it.

See what a little motivation can do?

One thing to watch out for -- Joe loves to prove to his guys that they're still "his guys." If Wang can't get us to the 7th inning, expect to see Mussina.

The thrill of victory, the agony of defeat

As one of those rare Yankee/Packer fan hybrids -- what can I say, I like teams that won a lot before I was born -- it was a mixed night for me.

The Yankees won, of course, to stave off elimination and play at least one more game in 2007. That was good.

The Packers, of course, blew a 10-point lead to lose to the hated Bears to ruin their perfect season.

I know a guy from Philadelphia, so naturally he is both a Phillies fan and an Eagles fan. Last Monday, I asked him if he was up (from the Phillies making the post-season) or down (from the Eagles losing to the Giants).

He thought about it for a little bit, then started trying to rationalize that he was up, but then he just sighed. "Goddamn it! Couldn't they have given me just one day to enjoy the moment?!"

I know a little better now where he was coming from, but I'm up, I'm up. If you told me in July that the Packers would be 4-1 and the Yankees would be in the post-season, I'd be a happy camper.

The Packers lost the type of game they'd been winning the first four games of the season. All the lucky breaks they got to get to 4-0 were here tonight -- for the Bears. Charles Woodson fumbles a punt and it bounces right into the hands of the punter, of all people, and he grabs it just before he slides out of bounds. Brett Favre does some kind of crazy no-look pass and throws it right into the arms of Brian Urlacher. The Bears go up on a touchdown pass that is caught out of bounds, but the officials rule it a push-out and, for god knows why, that's not a reviewable play. And speaking of reviewable plays, Mike McCarthy throws the red flag to challenge a spot, wins the challenge... or not. The announcers never seemed to figure this out. All I know is the officials picked up the ball and moved it back, which sounds like you won the challenge, right? But they didn't move it back far enough for it not to be a first down, so apparently he lost the challenge. In other words, yes, we made a mistake, but no, we didn't.

And then on top of the five turnovers, all those penalties -- 93 yards in penalties, and at killer times too. The Packers racked up 150 more yards of offense, but all for naught.

But at the end of the game, if Donald Driver jumps an inch higher, it's all tied up.

Yeah, so we could be 5-0, but then we could have just as easily lost the Eagles game or even the Giants game, and be 2-3. We're a good but not great team -- a better team than the Bears, but not tonight. Next week we're home against a 3-1 Redskins team that just beat the holy hell out of the Lions. We'll see which was the fluke, the first four or the last one.

As for the Yankees, win tomorrow and send the series back to Cleveland -- where the forecast for Wednesday night is high 50s and rain, not exactly good conditions for midges. Win tomorrow and try again with Chien-Ming Wang against C.C. Sabathia. Hopefully Wang will figure out whatever was wrong with him in Game 1, and hopefully the Yankee batters can figure out why they couldn't put away Sabathia, a guy we had on the ropes more than Rocky Balboa against Clubber Lang.



But unfortunately it was Rocky/Clubber II. Just like Clubber we kept going for the big knock-out punch but swinging and missing.

Before we can start thinking about Wednesday, we have to win tomorrow, and even with Paul Byrd pitching, it won't be easy. We won't have Phil Hughes (3.2 innings, 63 pitches) or Joba Chamberlain (2.0 innings, 38 pitches), which means the bullpen is going to be short-handed tomorrow night if Mike Mussina can't get us through the 6th inning.

Yes, you could say we needed to win tonight to get to tomorrow, but what the fuck, Joe Torre? You had a 5-run lead, why did you send Joba back out there to pitch the 8th? You don't think that was a good time to play sports psychologist with Kyle Farnsworth? Maybe let Russ Ohlendorf get back on the horse after getting slapped around in Game 1? Oh, no, let's burn up Joba. More great work from one of the winningest managers in MLB history.

Of course, Joe has a lot more confidence in Moose than I do, because Joe just loves his veterans. Johnny Damon after the game tonight was asked if it mattered that Torre's job was supposedly on the line tonight and he said something along the lines of, "We'll do anything for Joe." Hey, how about win some games in May and June, Johnny? Those games counted too, you know.

Well, obviously there's only one thing for Big Stein to do before tomorrow's game: Threaten to fire Joe again. Or, better yet, have a sniper in the owner's box with orders to shoot Torre in the head if the Yankees lose. Obviously it's the only way to motivate these guys. Win the game, or your beloved manager dies.

Can't you just picture Joe sitting there with the red dot of a laser sight bouncing over his forehead? Actually, he'd probably have his usual hang-dog look, staring at the ground, mumbling to himself and pounding down the green tea.

Bigelow Tea. Producer of fine quality teas since 1945. "Your bases are covered... with Bigelow Tea."

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

I don't want to hate Max Kellerman

I have the good fortune of working an 11-to-7 job, as opposed to 9-to-5, so I get to miss the morning traffic that would turn my 20-minute commute into an hour, but still get home early enough to have dinner or watch a Yankee game.

So during my drive I usually listen to Max Kellerman, who is on ESPN Radio from 10 a.m. to noon. And I really don't want to hate Max Kellerman. He's a young guy, he's sometimes funny, he pays attention to sabermetrics, he's a Yankee fan, he speaks Yiddish, he knows a lot about boxing, he bounced back from a horrifying tragedy, the murder of his 29-year-old brother. I root for Max Kellerman.


But every morning he says something that annoys me. Whether it's comparing Michael Vick's cruelty to dogs to eating breakfast or his inane "Max Kellerman Army" routine or his mind-bogglingly obvious and yet ridiculously stupid observation that if your offense was so good that you never made an out, you could never actually win a baseball game.

So I've come to expect every day that he will say something that will make me frown. And then I sigh to myself, "Aw Max, I don't want to hate you."

Yes, and people in other cars do look at me with pity.

This morning, I was going to let it slide when he said Phil Hughes is already the best starting pitcher in baseball. OK, whatever. Hyperbole from a Yankee fan is acceptable.

No, what annoyed me this morning was his argument that Johnny Damon is a better hitter than Melky Cabrera. Not that Cabrera's career won't be as good as Damon's, or that Damon was a better hitter at age 23 than Cabrera is, or anything like that. No, that at this moment in time, Damon is a better hitter than Cabrera.

Aggravating the annoyance factor: Kellerman came to the right conclusion for the wrong reason. He says that, when Jason Giambi comes back, Melky will be the odd man out.

I agree!

But then Max takes it a step further by saying that Melky should be the one on the bench.

With Giambi back, the Yankees will have four players (Giambi, Damon, Melky and Andy Phillips for three spots (first, center and DH). One of the four has to ride the pine.

Max argues that it should be Melky, saying that Damon is a better center fielder than Giambi is a first baseman, so you're not losing as much defensively by playing Damon in center over Cabrera as you would playing Giambi at first over Phillips.

Yeah, it's kind of like saying you'd rather bang Joan Rivers than Geraldo Rivera. Either way, it's going to be ugly and you're not going to brag about it.

No matter how bad Giambi is, he can still catch balls thrown directly at him by the other infielders, which is 99 percent of a first baseman's job. A good defensive first baseman is a bonus; a bad defensive center fielder is a nightmare. For the defense argument to work, you have to convince me that Damon is an adequate center fielder, and I just don't buy that. But you know what? Let's say he is.

Where Max really lost me is when he said, offensively, Damon is still a better hitter than Cabrera. Melky will be better one day, Max concedes -- saying that Cabrera's career numbers so far compare favorably to Bernie Williams -- but for the rest of this season, you'd rather have Damon hitting than Cabrera.

Huh?


Melky: .291/.348/.409, 14 2B, 5 HR, 9-2 SB in 330 AB
Damon: .247/.347/.344, 16 2B, 5 HR, 19-2 SB in 340 AB


Hm... well, Damon got off to a slow start. Maybe he means recently?


Melky in July: .373/.416/.510, 2 HR, 4-1 SB in 102 AB
Damon in July: .237/.370/.309, 0 HR, 6-2 SB in 97 AB


All right. Maybe he means lefty/righty?


Melky: .267/.342/.366 vs LHP, .301/.350/.428 vs RHP
Damon: .268/.345/.340 vs LHP, .239/.347/.346 vs RHP


I arrived at work and missed the end of the great Melky/Johnny debate, so maybe Kellerman had some brilliant point about how you can't look at the statistics. Maybe he said, "Yes, I know Cabrera has been better to this point this season, but he's just a kid and could fall apart. Damon, on the other hand, is a veteran hitter with a tremendous body of work who is bound to start hitting better over the last two months of the season." But now you've left the realm of the objective.

Yes, Damon could come around. Cabrera could fall on his face. Or not. One guy is turning 23 and the other turning 34. The last two months could be a fluke, but it's not like it would be unexpected for Cabrera to get better and Damon to get worse at their respective ages.

And yet after all that, what really annoys me to no end is that Kellerman is right. Cabrera will be on the bench and Damon will be in center field.

Why? Because Joe Torre loves veterans. That's all there is to it. He'll do his best to get Cabrera into games by giving outfielders a day off or giving Giambi the occasional start at first base, but barring an injury, I think you'll see more of Damon than you will of Cabrera from here on out. This is exactly why I didn't want the Yankees to bring Bernie back, because Torre would have found a way to play him every day no matter what.

What would I do? I'd have Cabrera in center and Phillips at first, with Damon and Giambi sharing the DH role depending on the match-up, maybe benching Phillips and stomaching Giambi at first if you're facing a tough righty. But that might ruffle some feathers, and Torre doesn't do that to his guys. Cabrera can wait 'til next year.

But c'mon, Max. Don't pretend to be a sabermetrics guy if you won't look at numbers.

Sunday, July 1, 2007

Proctor gets torched



Yankee reliever Scott Proctor burned his glove, cap and spikes yesterday after the A's lit him up for three runs on three hits in a third of an inning.

"I burned everything, the whole bit," Proctor said as he left Yankee Stadium. "I've done it before when things have gone bad. When I needed a change."

Some sources say Proctor burned his uniform; Proctor told the New York Post that's not true -- not that he didn't want to. "I'd burn my uniform if I wouldn't get in trouble for it."

You know what? I was never a big Proctor fan before, but I like him now. At least he seems to give a crap.

The Post's Michael Morrissey sniped, "And to think, it seemed Kyle Farnsworth was extreme for throwing his glove on Friday night."

But there's a big difference. Farnsworth-less threw a temper tantrum in front of the cameras when Joe Torre called on Mariano Rivera with two outs in the 8th. Now, given Mo just might be the greatest closer in the history of baseball, who the hell is Farnsworth to bitch about coming out? It's not like Torre pulled him for Charlie Brown. And a guy who has had three 1-2-3 innings this year -- that's right, just three 1-2-3 innings all year long -- and a 4.88 ERA and 1.66 WHIP has no right to complain about anything.

It was the second time in a week the cameras caught Farnsworth pitching a fit after getting pulled from a game. Just another sign Torre has lost control of this team.

Proctor, on the other hand, did his little pyro performance after the game, after the cameras were off. Even his teammates had already gone home.

Probably the only reason anybody heard about it is because some sportswriters were still hanging around in the press box, smelled something burning, and saw Proctor was doing some weekend grilling on the field in front of the Yankee dugout. And unlike Farnsworth, who refused to talk to reporters about his crybaby routines, Proctor manned up, joked about it and moved on.
I feel you, Prock. You can come over for a barbecue anytime you want.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Like two ships passing in the night... again

Wow.

Just two weeks ago I wrote about how the Yankees and the Mets had almost mirror records since the May subway series. After the Mets took two out of three at Shea, they went into the tank, going 8-13. Meanwhile, the Yankees turned around their season with a 14-8 record, including that astounding nine-game winning streak.

Then, the subway series in the Bronx. Yanks take two out of three. And both do a 180.


The Mets have gone 6-3 against a tough stretch of opponents. The Yankees, on the other hand, have gone 1-7 and lost three consecutive series, including four straight losses against the woeful Giants and Orioles. And once again, there are
calls for Joe Torre's head.

What would I do to fix this, were I advising George Steinbrenner? (
Jennifer -- call me.)

I would humbly present Big Stein with this simple five-point plan.


1. Fire Brian Cashman and Joe Torre. I have made the case against Torre before, so I won't belabor the point. In a nutshell, I think he is a very nice man but not a good manager. A decent manager could win with the talent we had 10 or even five years ago, but not now. Even worse, he's lost this team. Probably lost it a few seasons ago, actually. So you know I'd want Torre gone. But why go after Cash, man? I don't have anything against Ca$hMoney, but I think he and Torre have to go down together. At the end of last season, it could have been just Torre walking the plank, but Cashman did the old Backdraft "You go... we go" manuever. Sorry, Brian -- that didn't work out so well in the movie either. Who replaces them? Well, George, I know your super-duper secret plan is to let Don Mattingly be the manager some day, so you don't want to hire somebody like Joe Girardi who would get in Donnie Baseball's way. On the other hand, you don't want to give Mattingly the job now -- you don't want him inheriting someone else's mess, and also because he's essentially going to be the same low-key, hands-off manager Torre was, and you need to shake things up. So go ahead and give the job to Larry Bowa. If he can't turn the team around, fire his ass. If he gets the team back to the post-season, say nice job -- and then fire him anyway. Hell, you did it to Buck Showalter, and people actually liked Showalter. Either way, Donnie is the manager next year. As for your new GM, well, I do happen to have my resume right here...

2. Dump the dead weight. Did you know Chris Basak is on the 25-man roster? Apparently Torre didn't, either, because he was called up on June 5 and has been in just three games since then -- twice as a defensive replacement in blowouts, and once as a pinch-hitter (for Mike Mussina in San Francisco). Three weeks on the roster, three games, one plate appearance. Who does Joe think this kid is, Moonlight Graham? Put the poor guy on a bus back to Scranton. Next, put Johnny Damon on the D.L. -- he's been hitting .222 (.629 OPS) this month, and that doesn't include his 0-for-4 tonight. He can't play the outfield anymore. What's the point of having him taking up a spot on the roster? Let him get healthy and let Kevin Thompson play some outfield.

3. Find a legitimate first baseman. What kind of a world do we live in where Miguel Cairo is the starting first baseman for the New York Yankees? With Basak in the minors, Cairo goes back to being the utility infielder/team mascot and we get a real first baseman to take Basak's spot on the roster. It doesn't have to be Mark Teixeira or Paul Konerko. If the asking price for those guys is too high, grab whoever's cheap -- Shea Hillenbrand or Ty Wigginton or Dmitri Young or (my personal choice) Scott Hatteberg -- and if worse comes to worst, just call up Shelley Duncan (hitting .302/.388/.585 in Scranton, and how can you not love a guy named Shelley Duncan?) and let him duke it out with Andy Phillips.

4. Reinforce for the bullpen. With Damon on the D.L., call up RP Chris Britton. He has been great in Triple-A (2.25 ERA, 1.22 WHIP, 11 BB, 42 K in 36.0 IP) and wasn't bad for the Orioles last year (3.35 ERA, 1.17 WHIP, 17 BB, 41 K in 53.2 IP). Why has this guy been in Triple-A for three months while the Yankees' bullpen has been exploding? Next, tell Bowa to find out if Ron Villone has anything left -- and if not, cut him. Villone has given up 7 ER, 13 H and 5 BB in 12.0 IP this year, but he's appeared in just 10 games since they called him up from the minors on May 15. He had a two-week stretch in mid-June where Joe didn't use him at all. Well, either get him on track or release him. If we can't trade for a mediocre left-handed veteran on a bad team (Jamie Walker or Ron Mahay or Steve Kline), call up Sean Henn. Why the hell not.

5. Fire John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman. This won't help the Yankees, but it would do so much for the Yankee fans. It's the best way to apologize for the first three months of the season.

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Like two ships passing in the night

Would anyone have believed this after last month's subway series?

At the end of that weekend, May 18-20, the Mets were 28-15 after taking two out of three from the Yankees. The Bombers were 19-23.

Since then, the Yankees have gone 14-8, while the Mets have gone 8-13.

And going into tomorrow night's game, the Yankees -- after winning nine straight -- are 33-31. The Mets have lost five in a row, and are now 36-28.

If the Yankees sweep, the two teams will have the same record -- 36-31.

Unbelievable.

At least we found something Joe Torre can do to help the team. Bullpen management, lineup construction and in-game strategy aren't his strong points. But standing in the dugout while the Yankees are batting? He can do that, and apparently, it's been working. Supposedly he started this -- standing on the dugout steps, holding a bat -- during the May 30th game against the Blue Jays, which they won 10-5. Since then, they've gone 12-2.

The way I figure it, both Yankee fans and Met fans would be OK if the Yanks win two and the Mets win one. Of course both sides will say we want a sweep. But realistically, if the Yanks take two, Yankee fans will be happy to win another series and hopefully pick up another game on Boston and Detroit. Met fans will be happy to have ended their losing streak and to not get swept.

Roger Clemens vs. Oliver Perez tomorrow night. Ollie pitched well against the Yankees last month (2 ER, 5 H, 5 K in 7.2 IP). Clemens hasn't faced the Mets since April 2005, but shut them down (0 R, 2 H, 1 BB, 8 K). You'd have to figure this is advantage Yankees. But it is a dangerous game for the Yankees, almost a must-win, because if the Mets win this game, you could reasonably expect them to win two out of three.

Tyler Clippard vs. Tom Glavine on Saturday afternoon. The Yankees did OK against Glavine last time out (3 R, 9 H, 2 BB in 6.0 IP), though he did get the win; Clippard pitched that Sunday night game on ESPN, his MLB debut, and also won (1 R, 3 H, 3 BB, 6.0 IP). Still, you have to figure this game is advantage Mets, and that's why it's so important for the Yankees to win tomorrow.

Orlando Hernandez vs. Chien-Ming Wang on Sunday night (ESPN). El Duque is 0-3 lifetime against the Yankees, but he pitched OK against them last year (2 ER, 7 H, 1 BB, 7 IP). Wang has never faced the Mets before, but has won 3 games in a row (2.08 ERA, 1.11 WHIP in 21.2 IP). Advantage Yankees. Again I almost see this one as a must-win. In fact, if the Yankees don't sweep, they have to win this game and one other game this weekend -- win, lose, win or lose, win, win. If they win the first two but then lose Sunday night, on national TV, blowing their chance for a sweep, it's kind of bittersweet. I want to go into work on Monday coming off a win, not a loss.

In fact, I want to go to work Monday with the same record as the Mets.

What a difference a month makes.

Monday, May 28, 2007

The Joe Torre story

As I have noted before, I am not a fan of Joe Torre.

I think there is a misconception among Yankee haters that Yankee fans think Torre is a great manager. That may be true, or may have been true anyway, when it comes to the casual Yankee fan. (Now there's no shortage of Yankee fans blaming Torre for all that is wrong with the world.)
But there are many Yankee fans, including me, who didn't like Torre when he was hired 11 years ago and don't like him now, four rings or no.

Sometimes I think the case against Torre is overstated -- I do not, for example, believe he is a sign of the impending apocalpyse -- but it also sets my teeth on edge when I hear John Sterling, Suzyn Waldman and Michael Kay blasting Torre's critics as ingrates ("I guess 1996-2000 wasn't good enough for you?"), hypocrites ("no one was complaining when he won four World Series rings!") or second-guessers ("if Kyle Farnsworth had struck out the side, people would say Torre is a genius!").

Isn't it possible to be a Yankee fan and still not like Torre as manager? Heck, isn't it possible that Torre was the right manager a few years ago, but is the wrong manager now?

Torre is a player's manager -- hands-off, laid-back, low-key. He won't jump up and high-five you after a great play, and he won't get in your face and scream after a dumb one. He prefers veterans over rookies, and "his guys" over newcomers. If you are one of his guys, you don't have to worry about losing your job. You'll have time to work through your slump. Joe will protect you.
It must be a comfortable place to work. And sometimes that's a good thing, and sometimes that's a bad thing.

When Torre came to the Yankees, there were a number of players -- Joe Girardi, Tino Martinez, Jim Leyritz -- who did the yelling and screaming for him. (At the time, I assumed Paul O'Neill was the in-your-face guy in the dugout, but since then I've heard that O'Neill was always screaming at himself, not at other people.) Scott Brosius would later play this role as well.

There isn't a player like that now. Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez are the lead-by-example types. Jorge Posada sometimes yells, but not always. He seems to direct most of his ire at the other team anyway. Larry Bowa is a screamer, but he's the third base coach, not the manager.

The problem with being a player's manager is if you try to do something different, now you're an asshole. Look at it this way: if Torre demands that Melky Cabrera gets sent down to Triple-A and that Luis Vizcaino gets released, well, then Torre's a traitor. He's throwing guys under the bus to save his own job. (Look at how Philly fans killed Charlie Manuel for putting Brett Myers in the bullpen.)

But if a new guy comes in and does the same thing, hey, he's cleaning house.

The truth is I don't think there's much that can really be done with the Yankees. Maybe you send Cabrera down to figure things out, or at least call up Kevin Thompson so we have another option. You can upgrade at backup catcher over Wil Nieves... woo-hoo. The best possible upgrade on offense would be a real first baseman to replace Doush Phelkiewicz.

For all the bluster about releasing Vizcaino, remember this guy was pretty good last year (3.58 ERA, 1.22 WHIP) for Arizona and not bad the year before that (3.73 ERA, 1.47 WHIP) for the White Sox. The same goes for Kyle Farnsworth, who despite all his struggles might be worth something in trade back to the N.L. There's obviously room to upgrade the middle relief.

There's nothing that can be done about the rotation except wait for the return of Roger Clemens and Phil Hughes -- if we trade for a guy, it would mean sending Hughes back to Triple-A, unless you want to put a hit on Mike Mussina.

So what's Joe's replacement going to do, other than yell and scream?

All that said, if it were my team... I'd fire him. But then again, I would've fired him last year, too.

Saturday, May 19, 2007

Who can we blame for this? Part 2

Last month I asked who can we blame for the Yankees' disappointing start, and a few days later the Yankees answered by firing the performance enhancement director.

Record before Marty Miller was fired: 10-14. Record since then: 8-8.

OK, so that was obviously a step in the right direction. Plus we haven't had any hamstring injuries since then. So kudos to the Yankees for firing Miller.

Unfortunately, even if we can keep up this impressive .500 performance of the post-Miller era, it won't be enough to get us back into the post-season. (Unless we can convince the Red Sox to hire Marty.)

As a diehard Yankee fan, of course I think we're going to go on a 122-game winning streak and finish the season with the best record in baseball. But now that we're officially a quarter of the way through the season, what would be a realistic number to throw out there for the Yankees' win total?

Now, before the season started, I said the Yankees would win 100 games. Appropriately, I titled that post "What the hell do I know?" But let's say the Yankees truly are a 100-win team -- which would be a .617 winning percentage -- that got off to a bad start.

Starting at 18-22, if we play .617 baseball over the final three quarters of the season, we go 75-47 -- and finish the year at 93-69.

In fact, Paul Katcher just blogged earlier this week that, going by Pythagorean winning percentage, the Yankees are really a 94-win team. So let's say 93-69 is a reasonable target -- which would mean no one else gets hurt, but also that Roger Clemens and Phil Hughes don't make much of a difference. We're essentially the same team we are now but some of the breaks start going our way.

Oddly enough, the Red Sox also have played 40 games, but they are 28-12. For us to pass them, they'd have to finish the season going 64-58 (.525 W%). That would leave them at 92-70. And you know what? I don't think that's impossible.

I'm sure Boston fans will scoff at anything less than a .700 winning percentage the rest of the way, but .700 might be more unrealistic than .525. So far they've avoided any major injuries, and they've been getting amazing -- a cynic would say unsustainably amazing -- performances from their pitching staff. Last year they were 86-76, which is just one win better than a .525 W%. On the other hand, you could also point out that they're a better team that they were last year, or that this year they have a .700 Pythagorean winning percentage and that's without any production from J.D. Drew or Manny Ramirez.

It's too early to write off the A.L. East, but just for a moment, what about the wild card? Right now, the Detroit Tigers are leading at 25-16 (.610 W%). If we assume the Yankees win 93 games, the Tigers would have to go 67-54 (.554 W%) to finish at 92-70. Is that unrealistic? Well, if they play in line with their current Pythagorean winning percentage (.561 W%), they would go 68-53 -- which would leave them tied with us at 93 wins.

I know on a cold and gray May morning, coming off a tough loss last night in which we were shut down by yet another lefty, this may look like a lost season. But have hope. We still have a lot of baseball left to play, and the numbers above aren't unrealistic. Clemens and Hughes are coming back, Mariano Rivera is looking better, the offense will start clicking soon.

And if worse comes to worst, we can always fire the assistant to the traveling secretary.